How we checked The Brontës’ Tiny Books
We listed every fact the film states, 73 in all, and checked each one against a source. For each one, here are the narrator’s words, the source’s own words, and what we found: 70 supported, 3 overstated.
From 0:00
-
0:00 “This is a magazine, just over five centimetres tall.”
The source says this.
Measuring about 2.5 by 5 centimeters
-
0:04 “Charlotte Brontë writes it in August 1829”
The source says this.
Homemade miniature issue of Blackwoods young mens magazine (August 1829) by English novelist and poet Charlotte Brontë
MS Lowell 1 (6), Blackwoods young mens magazine, August 1829, Houghton Library, Harvard University, on Wikimedia Commons, a document of the time
-
0:04 “when she is thirteen”
The source says this.
Here, at Thornton, Charlotte Bronte was born, on the 21st of April, 1816.
Elizabeth Gaskell, The Life of Charlotte Brontë, 1857, volume 1, Internet Archive
-
0:09 “She writes a whole series of them.”
The source says this.
The Young Men’s Magazines, in Six Numbers, from August to December,
Elizabeth Gaskell, The Life of Charlotte Brontë, 1857, volume 1, Internet Archive, a document of the time
-
0:12 “In 2019 the Brontë Society pays six hundred and sixty-seven thousand pounds”
The source says this.
The total price including buyer’s premium was €780,000 (£666,790).
Rare Charlotte Bronte book coming home after museum's auction success, BBC News, 18 November 2019, a document of the time
-
0:12 “pays six hundred and sixty-seven thousand pounds for just one.”
The source says this.
written by Charlotte, the eldest of the three sisters, in 1830
Rare Charlotte Bronte book coming home after museum's auction success, BBC News, 18 November 2019, a document of the time
The sources disagree: Sotheby’s 2011 sale notice, the BBC and the room’s note call this magazine Number 2, dated August 1830; the Brontë Society’s own announcement in 2019 calls it the fifth of the six and says Number 2 has been lost since about 1930.
-
0:20 “Their first readers are twelve wooden soldiers.”
The source says this.
In 1826, shortly before Branwell’s ninth birthday his father gave him twelve little soldiers.
-
0:20 “Their first readers are twelve wooden soldiers.”
The source says this.
which were both the protagonists of and audience for the little books
The genesis of genius, Harvard Gazette, June 2014
The sources disagree: Charlotte’s schoolfriend Mary Taylor, whom Gaskell calls ‘Mary’, wrote that no one wrote in the magazine and no one read it but Charlotte, her brother and her two sisters.
-
0:27 “Haworth is a village on a steep hillside in the West Riding of Yorkshire, with moors rising behind it.”
The source says this.
situated on the side of a pretty steep hill, with a back-ground of dun and purple moors, rising and sweeping away yet higher than the church,
Elizabeth Gaskell, The Life of Charlotte Brontë, 1857, volume 1, Internet Archive
-
0:29 “in the West Riding of Yorkshire”
The source says this.
and wapentake of Morley, West Riding — Haworth being ten miles
Clement Shorter, The Brontës: Life and Letters, 1908, volume 1, Internet Archive, a document of the time
-
0:33 “In 1826 four children live in the parsonage there: Charlotte, Branwell, Emily and Anne.”
The source says this.
old, when Mr. Bronte removed to Haworth, on February the 25th, 1820.
Elizabeth Gaskell, The Life of Charlotte Brontë, 1857, volume 1, Internet Archive
-
0:41 “Their father, Patrick, is the parson.”
The source says this.
REV. P. BRONTE, A.B., MINISTER OF HAWORTH.
Elizabeth Gaskell, The Life of Charlotte Brontë, 1857, volume 1, Internet Archive, a document of the time
-
0:44 “Their mother and their two elder sisters have died.”
The source says this.
DEPARTED TO THE SAVIOUR, SEPT. 15TH, 1821,
Elizabeth Gaskell, The Life of Charlotte Brontë, 1857, volume 1, Internet Archive, a document of the time
-
0:44 “Their mother and their two elder sisters have died.”
The source says this.
6TH OF MAY, 1825, IN THE 12TH YEAR OF HER AGE;
Elizabeth Gaskell, The Life of Charlotte Brontë, 1857, volume 1, Internet Archive, a document of the time
-
0:48 “Charlotte is ten.”
The source says this.
Here, at Thornton, Charlotte Bronte was born, on the 21st of April, 1816.
Elizabeth Gaskell, The Life of Charlotte Brontë, 1857, volume 1, Internet Archive
-
0:50 “Anne, the youngest, is six.”
The source says this.
be 25 years and 6 months old, Emily will be 27 years old,
Clement Shorter, Charlotte Brontë and Her Circle, 1896, Internet Archive, a document of the time
-
0:52 “One night in June, their father comes home from Leeds”
The source says this.
established; ‘Young Men,’ June, 1826; ‘Our Fellows,’ July, 1827;
Elizabeth Gaskell, The Life of Charlotte Brontë, 1857, volume 1, Internet Archive, a document of the time
-
0:52 “their father comes home from Leeds with a box of wooden soldiers for Branwell.”
The source says this.
Branwell some wooden soldiers at Leeds; when Papa came home it was night, and we were in bed, so next morning Branwell came to our door with a box of soldiers.
Elizabeth Gaskell, The Life of Charlotte Brontë, 1857, volume 1, Internet Archive, a document of the time
-
0:58 “Three years later, Charlotte writes down what happens the next morning.”
The source says this.
I will sketch out the origins of our plays more explicitly if I can. March 12, 1829.
From 1:00
-
1:03 “… Emily and I jumped out of bed, and I snatched up one and exclaimed, ‘This is the Duke of Wellington! This shall be the Duke!’”
The source says this.
exclaimed, ‘This is the Duke of Wellington! This shall be the Duke!’
Elizabeth Gaskell, The Life of Charlotte Brontë, 1857, volume 1, Internet Archive, a document of the time
The sources disagree: Modern transcriptions of Charlotte’s manuscript, in Wikipedia’s Gondal article and on annebronte.org, read ‘this is the Duke of Wellington it shall be mine!!’, not Gaskell’s ‘This shall be the Duke!’.
-
1:13 “Emily’s was a grave-looking fellow, and we called him ‘Gravey.’ Anne’s was a queer little thing, much like herself, and we called him ‘Waiting-Boy.’ Branwell chose his, and called him ‘Buonaparte.’”
The source says this.
Emily’s was a grave-looking fellow, and we called him ‘Gravey.’ Anne’s was a queer little thing, much like herself, and we called him ‘Waiting-Boy.’ Branwell chose his, and called him ‘Buonaparte.’
Elizabeth Gaskell, The Life of Charlotte Brontë, 1857, volume 1, Internet Archive, a document of the time
The sources disagree: Modern transcriptions of the manuscript, on annebronte.org and in Wikipedia’s Gondal article, read ‘He was called Waiting Boy. Branwell chose Bonaparte.’, not Gaskell’s ‘we called him Waiting-Boy. Branwell chose his, and called him Buonaparte.’
-
1:24 “The children give the soldiers a country, on the coast of West Africa.”
The source says this.
On reaching the shores of West Africa, the Twelves (as the company is known) set up a colonial outpost, and lay claim to land as their own.
-
1:28 “Its capital is Glass Town.”
The source says this.
This contains the Great Glass Town capital, (later known as ‘ Verreopolis ’ or ‘ Verdopolis ’).
-
1:31 “The four children rule it as the Genii, spirits with magic powers.”
The source says this.
vast wilderness of space, inhabited only by the four high princes of
Elizabeth Gaskell, The Life of Charlotte Brontë, 1857, volume 1, Internet Archive, a document of the time
-
1:37 “One night in December 1827”
The source says this.
The play of the ‘Islanders’ was formed in December, 1827, in the
Elizabeth Gaskell, The Life of Charlotte Brontë, 1857, volume 1, Internet Archive, a document of the time
-
1:40 “the four sit by the kitchen fire with Tabby, the servant.”
The source says this.
the warm blazing kitchen fire, having just concluded a quarrel with
Elizabeth Gaskell, The Life of Charlotte Brontë, 1857, volume 1, Internet Archive, a document of the time
-
1:44 “They have just lost an argument with her about lighting a candle.”
The source says this.
Tabby concerning the propriety of lighting a candle, from which she
Elizabeth Gaskell, The Life of Charlotte Brontë, 1857, volume 1, Internet Archive, a document of the time
-
1:48 “BRANWELL: I don’t know what to do. TABBY: Wha ya may go t’ bed. BRANWELL: I’d rather do anything than that. CHARLOTTE: … Oh! suppose we had each an island of our own.”
The source says this.
“_Tabby_. ‘Wha ya may go t’ bed.’ “_Branwell_. ‘I’d rather do anything than that.’
Elizabeth Gaskell, The Life of Charlotte Brontë, 1857, volume 1, Internet Archive, a document of the time
From 2:00
-
2:00 “Each child picks an island, and the men who will rule it.”
The source says this.
We then chose who should be chief men in our islands.
Elizabeth Gaskell, The Life of Charlotte Brontë, 1857, volume 1, Internet Archive, a document of the time
-
2:03 “Then the clock strikes seven, and they have to go to bed.”
The source says this.
was interrupted by the, to us, dismal sound of the clock striking seven, and we were summoned off to bed.
Elizabeth Gaskell, The Life of Charlotte Brontë, 1857, volume 1, Internet Archive, a document of the time
-
2:08 “A neighbour lends them Blackwood’s”
The source says less than this. Charlotte names the lender only as Mr. Driver. No source I could fetch says who he was or where he lived, so ‘a neighbour’ is a guess.
Mr. Driver lends us it, as likewise ‘Blackwood’s Magazine,’ the most able periodical there is.
Elizabeth Gaskell, The Life of Charlotte Brontë, 1857, volume 1, Internet Archive, a document of the time
-
2:08 “Blackwood’s, a magazine from Edinburgh.”
The source says this.
EDINBURGH: WILLIAM BLACKWOOD, NO. 17, PRINCE’S STREET, EDINBURGH
Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, No. 148, January 1829, Internet Archive, a document of the time
-
2:12 “In January 1829 Branwell starts a magazine like it”
The source says this.
By Patrick Branwell Brontë: Branwells Blackwoods magazine , June 1829 Magazine , January 1829 Branwells Blackwoods magazine , July 1829
-
2:16 “for the soldiers, at their size.”
The source says this.
the Brontës initially made the books in miniature to scale them to Branwell’s toy soldiers
-
2:18 “That August, Charlotte takes it over as editor.”
The source says this.
The new one is the Cheif Genius Charlotte. She will conduct it in future, tho’ I shall write now and then for it.
Liz Maynes-Aminzade, Literary Fetishes: The Brontë Miniature Books, Harvard Library Bulletin 24 (2), 2014, a document of the time
-
2:28 “They write in tiny letters that look like print.”
The source says this.
The MS. is written, except for the preface (f. 2b), in minute characters in imitation of print.
The Search after Hapiness, by Charlotte Brontë, Ashley MS 156, British Library, a document of the time
-
2:31 “By August 1830, Charlotte has written twenty-two little books”
The source says this.
Making in the whole twenty-two volumes.
Elizabeth Gaskell, The Life of Charlotte Brontë, 1857, volume 1, Internet Archive, a document of the time
-
2:35 “in about fifteen months.”
The source says this.
it was all written in about fifteen months.
Elizabeth Gaskell, The Life of Charlotte Brontë, 1857, volume 1, Internet Archive
-
2:37 “On one title page, she adds a line like a real printer’s.”
The source says this.
PRINTED BY HERSELF AND SOLD BY NOBODY &ct &ct
Clement Shorter, The Brontës: Life and Letters, 1908, volume 1, Project Gutenberg, a document of the time
-
2:42 “Printed by herself and sold by nobody”
The source says this.
PRINTED BY HERSELF AND SOLD BY NOBODY &ct &ct
Clement Shorter, The Brontës: Life and Letters, 1908, volume 1, Project Gutenberg, a document of the time
-
2:47 “In 1831 Charlotte goes away to school.”
The source says this.
In January, 1831, Charlotte was sent to school again.
Elizabeth Gaskell, The Life of Charlotte Brontë, 1857, volume 1, Internet Archive
-
2:50 “Emily and Anne make up a country of their own, called Gondal.”
The source says this.
the two younger siblings later collaborated on their own competing series, set in the kingdom of “Gondal”
The sources disagree: No source I could open dates Gondal’s start to 1831, after Charlotte left. Wikipedia’s date rests on a children’s book (Smith Kenyon, 2002). The first mention I could open is in Emily’s diary paper of 24 November 1834, which Nick Holland transcribes: “The Gondals are discovering the interior of Gaaldine”.
-
2:54 “They are still writing about it as grown women.”
The source says this.
Gondals still flourish bright as ever
Clement Shorter, Charlotte Brontë and Her Circle, 1896, Internet Archive, a document of the time
-
2:58 “In the autumn of 1845, Charlotte finds a notebook of Emily’s poems”
The source says this.
“One day in the autumn of 1845, I accidentally lighted on a MS. volume
Elizabeth Gaskell, The Life of Charlotte Brontë, 1857, volume 1, Internet Archive, a document of the time
From 3:00
-
3:02 “and thinks they are good.”
The source says this.
I thought them condensed and terse, vigorous and
Elizabeth Gaskell, The Life of Charlotte Brontë, 1857, volume 1, Internet Archive, a document of the time
-
3:05 “We had very early cherished the dream of one day being authors.”
The source says this.
We had very early cherished the dream of one day being authors.
Elizabeth Gaskell, The Life of Charlotte Brontë, 1857, volume 1, Internet Archive, a document of the time
-
3:10 “In 1846 the three sisters publish their poems together.”
The source says this.
Poems by Currer, Ellis, and Acton Bell. Loyidon : Aylott and Jones, 8 Paternoster Row. 1 846.
Clement Shorter, The Brontës: Life and Letters, 1908, volume 1, Internet Archive, a document of the time
-
3:14 “They don’t want readers to know they are women.”
The source says this.
Christian names, positively masculine, while we did not like to declare ourselves women, because
Elizabeth Gaskell, The Life of Charlotte Brontë, 1857, volume 1, Internet Archive, a document of the time
-
3:16 “So they call themselves Currer, Ellis and Acton Bell.”
The source says this.
names under those of Currer, Ellis, and Acton Bell; the ambiguous
Elizabeth Gaskell, The Life of Charlotte Brontë, 1857, volume 1, Internet Archive, a document of the time
-
3:21 “A year later, Charlotte sends a copy to the writer Thomas De Quincey”
The source says this.
not sell ; and we beg to offer you one in acknowledgment of the
Clement Shorter, The Brontës: Life and Letters, 1908, volume 1, Internet Archive, a document of the time
-
3:25 “and tells him how it has sold.”
The source says this.
space of a year our publisher has disposed but of two copies, and
Clement Shorter, The Brontës: Life and Letters, 1908, volume 1, Internet Archive, a document of the time
-
3:27 “In the space of a year our publisher has disposed but of two copies, and by what painful efforts he succeeded in getting rid of these two, himself only knows.”
The source says this.
space of a year our publisher has disposed but of two copies, and by what painful efforts he succeeded in getting rid of these two,
Clement Shorter, The Brontës: Life and Letters, 1908, volume 1, Internet Archive, a document of the time
-
3:38 “By then each sister has written a novel.”
The source says this.
The three tales had tried their fate in vain together, at length they
Elizabeth Gaskell, The Life of Charlotte Brontë, 1857, volume 2, Internet Archive
-
3:40 “In October 1847 Charlotte’s Jane Eyre comes out.”
The source says this.
“Gentlemen,--The six copies of “Jane Eyre” reached me this morning.
Elizabeth Gaskell, The Life of Charlotte Brontë, 1857, volume 2, Internet Archive, a document of the time
-
3:45 “In December, Emily’s Wuthering Heights and Anne’s Agnes Grey come out together.”
The source says this.
Wuthering Heights is, I suppose, at length published, at least Mr. Newby has sent the authors their six copies.
Clement Shorter, The Brontës: Life and Letters, 1908, volume 1, Internet Archive, a document of the time
-
3:52 “Branwell dies in September 1848.”
The source says this.
Also, of Patrick Branwell, their son, who died Sept. 24th, 1848, aged 31
Elizabeth Gaskell, The Life of Charlotte Brontë, 1857, volume 1, Internet Archive, a document of the time
-
3:55 “Emily dies in December”
The source says this.
Also, of Emily Jane, their daughter, who died Dec. 19th, 1848, aged 30
Elizabeth Gaskell, The Life of Charlotte Brontë, 1857, volume 1, Internet Archive, a document of the time
-
3:55 “and Anne the next May.”
The source says this.
Also, of Anne, their daughter, who died May 28th, 1849, aged 29 years.
Elizabeth Gaskell, The Life of Charlotte Brontë, 1857, volume 1, Internet Archive, a document of the time
From 4:00
-
4:00 “Charlotte dies in 1855.”
The source says this.
She died March 31st, 1855, in the 39th year of her age.
Elizabeth Gaskell, The Life of Charlotte Brontë, 1857, volume 1, Internet Archive, a document of the time
-
4:05 “After Charlotte dies, her husband sells the little books.”
The source says less than this. The Harvard Gazette says her husband sold the volumes after her death. Shorter, who got them, first visited Nicholls on 31 March 1895, forty years to the day after Charlotte died, and says Nicholls placed all his papers in his hands. Wikipedia’s article on Nicholls says Shorter persuaded him to sell, and that after Nicholls died in 1906 his widow sold the remaining manuscripts at auction in 1907, 1914 and 1916. So the line leaves out forty years, and not every book went through his hands.
Mr. Nicholls placed all the papers in his possession in my hands.
Clement Shorter, Charlotte Brontë and Her Circle, 1896, Internet Archive, a document of the time
The sources disagree: Banta (Harvard Library Bulletin, 2014) says Shorter bought the juvenilia from Nicholls in 1892, citing Shorter (1896), p. 25; Shorter (1896) dates his first visit to Nicholls to 31 March 1895.
-
4:09 “Collectors split them up.”
The source says this.
Wise distinguished himself as a bibliographer, collector, and, as it later became known, a brilliant forger. He sold some of the miniatures
-
4:11 “Harvard’s library has nine.”
The source says this.
Harvard holds nine, the Brontë Museum at the family home in England owns a few
-
4:13 “In 2011, one of Charlotte’s magazines comes up for sale in London.”
The source says this.
after being sold for £690,850 at Sotheby’s in London.
Charlotte Bronte manuscript bought for £690,000 by Paris museum — History News Network
-
4:17 “The Brontë Society bids for it, but a museum in Paris pays more.”
The source says this.
It outbid the Bronte Parsonage Museum, based in the family’s former house in Haworth, West Yorkshire.
Paris museum wins Bronte bidding war, BBC News, 15 December 2011, a document of the time
-
4:22 “In 2019 the magazine is for sale again, in Paris.”
The source says this.
went under the hammer at the Drouot auction house in Paris
Miniature autograph manuscript (the 'Little Book') | Friends of the National Libraries
-
4:26 “More than a thousand people give money”
The source says this.
The society said more than 1,000 people had pledged money to help buy the book.
Rare Charlotte Bronte book coming home after museum's auction success, BBC News, 18 November 2019, a document of the time
-
4:28 “and this time the Brontë Society buys it.”
The source says less than this. The society bought it, but most of the money came from elsewhere. Its own announcement credits a grant from the National Heritage Memorial Fund, and gifts from the Friends of the National Libraries, six trusts and Maggs Bros. The more than 1,000 supporters gave over £85,000 of the £666,790 total.
In addition the Society raised over £85k with over 1,000 supporters through the charity’s first ever public Crowdfunder campaign.
Charlotte Brontë's 'Little Book' Will Return Home to Haworth, Fine Books & Collections, a document of the time
-
4:31 “The magazine has a story about a murderer who goes mad.”
The source says this.
describes a murderer driven to madness after being haunted by his victims
Rare Charlotte Bronte book coming home after museum's auction success, BBC News, 18 November 2019
-
4:35 “A fire burns in his head, and his bed curtains catch fire.”
The source says this.
burning in his head causes his bed curtains to set alight
Rare Charlotte Bronte book coming home after museum's auction success, BBC News, 18 November 2019
-
4:39 “Seventeen years later, in Jane Eyre”
The source says this.
which Charlotte would publish 17 years later
Rare Charlotte Bronte book coming home after museum's auction success, BBC News, 18 November 2019
-
4:41 “a woman sets fire to the curtains around Mr Rochester’s bed.”
The source says this.
who is kept in the attic, seeks revenge by setting fire to his bed curtains
Paris museum wins Bronte bidding war, BBC News, 15 December 2011
-
4:46 “The magazine is back at the parsonage now”
The source says this.
The Little Book is now on display at the Brontë Parsonage Museum
Miniature autograph manuscript (the 'Little Book') | Friends of the National Libraries
-
4:48 “with four others from the same set.”
The source says this.
Five are known to survive, and the Bronte Parsonage Museum already holds the other four.
Rare Charlotte Bronte book coming home after museum's auction success, BBC News, 18 November 2019, a document of the time