How we checked The Hand of Glory

We listed every fact the film states, 44 in all, and checked each one against a source. For each one, here are the narrator’s words, the source’s own words, and what we found: 44 supported.

Back to the film

Facts 1 to 10

  1. “Early in the last century”

    The source says this.

    discovered in the early twentieth century hidden on the wall of a thatched cottage in Castleton

    The Hand of Glory, Whitby Museum

    The sources disagree: Wikipedia’s Castleton article says the hand was found in 1935, the year the museum says it was given.

  2. “in Castleton, a village on the North York Moors”

    The source says this.

    a hamlet in the township and parish of Danby, wapentake of Langbarugh, 9 miles S. E. from Guisborough … situated on a small eminence, surrounded by the Cleveland Moors

    Stephen Reynolds Clarke, The New Yorkshire Gazetteer, 1828, Internet Archive, a document of the time

  3. “a human hand turns up, hidden in the wall of a thatched cottage.”

    The source says this.

    hidden on the wall of a thatched cottage in Castleton

    The Hand of Glory, Whitby Museum

  4. “It has been dried.”

    The source says this.

    The mummified severed human hand

    The Hand of Glory, Whitby Museum

  5. “Joseph Ford, a stonemason and local historian, knows at once what he thinks it is.”

    The source says this.

    by a stonemason and local historian, Joseph Ford. He immediately identified it from popular stories

    The Hand of Glory, Whitby Museum

  6. “In 1787, Francis Grose ends his book of country words and superstitions with one from abroad, believed in France, Germany and Spain.”

    The source says this.

    a foreign piece of Superstition, firmly believed in many parts of France, Germany, and Spain

    Francis Grose, A Provincial Glossary, with a Collection of Local Proverbs, and Popular Superstitions, 1787, Internet Archive, a document of the time

  7. “A judge, he says, heard it from criminals who confessed under torture.”

    The source says this.

    I have thrice assisted at the definitive judgment of certain criminals, who, under the torture, confessed having used it

    Francis Grose, A Provincial Glossary, with a Collection of Local Proverbs, and Popular Superstitions, 1787, Internet Archive, a document of the time

  8. “It is called the Hand of Glory.”

    The source says this.

    Of the Hand of Glory, which is made use of by housebreakers

    Francis Grose, A Provincial Glossary, with a Collection of Local Proverbs, and Popular Superstitions, 1787, Internet Archive, a document of the time

  9. “Take the hand, left or right, of a person hanged, and exposed on the highway; wrap it up in a piece of a shroud, or winding sheet, in which let it be well squeezed, to get out any small quantity of blood that may have remained in it …”

    The source says this.

    Take the hand, left or right, of a person hanged, and exposed on the highway; wrap it up in a piece of a shroud, or winding sheet, in which let it be well squeezed, to get out any small quantity of blood that may have remained in it

    Francis Grose, A Provincial Glossary, with a Collection of Local Proverbs, and Popular Superstitions, 1787, Internet Archive, a document of the time

  10. “The hand is pickled for fifteen days, in salt, saltpetre and long pepper”

    The source says this.

    zimat, saltpetre, salt, and long pepper, the whole well powdered; leave it fifteen days in that vessel

    Francis Grose, A Provincial Glossary, with a Collection of Local Proverbs, and Popular Superstitions, 1787, Internet Archive, a document of the time

Facts 11 to 20

  1. “then dried in the summer sun.”

    The source says this.

    expose it to the noontide sun in the dog days

    Francis Grose, A Provincial Glossary, with a Collection of Local Proverbs, and Popular Superstitions, 1787, Internet Archive, a document of the time

  2. “A candle is made with a hanged man’s fat. The hand holds the candle.”

    The source says this.

    a kind of candle with the fat of a hanged man, virgin wax, and sisame of Lapland. The Hand of Glory is used as a candlestick to hold this candle

    Francis Grose, A Provincial Glossary, with a Collection of Local Proverbs, and Popular Superstitions, 1787, Internet Archive, a document of the time

  3. “Its properties are, that wheresoever any one goes with this dreadful instrument, the persons to whom it is presented will be deprived of all power of motion.”

    The source says this.

    Its properties are, that wheresoever any one goes with this dreadful instrument, the persons to whom it is presented will be deprived of all power of motion

    Francis Grose, A Provincial Glossary, with a Collection of Local Proverbs, and Popular Superstitions, 1787, Internet Archive, a document of the time

  4. “Smear the doorstep with the gall of a black cat, the fat of a white hen, and the blood of a screech owl.”

    The source says this.

    the gall of a black cat, the fat of a white hen, and the blood of a screech owl

    Francis Grose, A Provincial Glossary, with a Collection of Local Proverbs, and Popular Superstitions, 1787, Internet Archive, a document of the time

  5. “Those are the last words of his book.”

    The source says this.

    which mixture must necessarily be prepared during the dog days

    Francis Grose, A Provincial Glossary, with a Collection of Local Proverbs, and Popular Superstitions, 1787, Internet Archive, a document of the time

  6. “In England, after a murderer was hanged, the body could be hung in chains by the road, and left there.”

    The source says this.

    the Murder Act (1752), which specified that the bodies of murderers had to be either dissected or hung in chains

    Sarah Tarlow, The Golden and Ghoulish Age of the Gibbet in Britain, Palgrave Macmillan, 2017, open access, Internet Archive

  7. “Parliament stopped it in 1834.”

    The source says this.

    to abolish the Practice of hanging the Bodies of Criminals in Chains. [25th July 1834.]

    An Act to abolish the Practice of hanging the Bodies of Criminals in Chains, 4 & 5 Will. 4 c. 26, 25 July 1834, in The Statutes of the United Kingdom, Internet Archive, a document of the time

  8. “In 1565 Pieter Bruegel designs a print of a sorcerer’s den.”

    The source says this.

    1565

    Pieter van der Heyden after Pieter Bruegel the Elder, St. James and the Magician Hermogenes, 1565, the Metropolitan Museum of Art, a document of the time

  9. “One evening in the 1790s, a traveller in women’s clothes comes to the Old Spital Inn”

    The source says this.

    the years 1790 and 1800, a traveller, dressed in woman’s clothes, arrived at the Old Spital Inn

    William Henderson, Notes on the Folk-Lore of the Northern Counties of England and the Borders, 1879, Internet Archive

  10. “high on Bowes Moor, where the mail coach changes horses.”

    The source says this.

    the place where the mail coach changed horses, in High Spital, on Bowes Moor

    William Henderson, Notes on the Folk-Lore of the Northern Counties of England and the Borders, 1879, Internet Archive

Facts 21 to 30

  1. “The Hand of Glory reaches Yorkshire too.”

    The source says this.

    A History of the County of York North Riding: Volume 1 … This inn must have been the Old Spital Inn

    'Parishes: Bowes', A History of the County of York North Riding: Volume 1, ed. William Page, 1914, British History Online

  2. “The girl lies down on the settle by the fire.”

    The source says this.

    The girl lay down for a nap on the long settle by the fire

    William Henderson, Notes on the Folk-Lore of the Northern Counties of England and the Borders, 1879, Internet Archive

  3. “she sees a pair of man’s trousers under the gown.”

    The source says this.

    espied a pair of man’s trousers peeping out from under the gown

    William Henderson, Notes on the Folk-Lore of the Northern Counties of England and the Borders, 1879, Internet Archive

  4. “She pretends to sleep. She even snores.”

    The source says this.

    closed her eyes, and even began to snore

    William Henderson, Notes on the Folk-Lore of the Northern Counties of England and the Borders, 1879, Internet Archive

  5. “The traveller takes a dead man’s hand from his pocket, fits a candle to it, lights it, and passes it in front of her face.”

    The source says this.

    pulled out of his pocket a dead man’s hand, fitted a candle to it, lighted the candle, and passed hand and candle several times before the servant-girl’s face

    William Henderson, Notes on the Folk-Lore of the Northern Counties of England and the Borders, 1879, Internet Archive

  6. “Let those who are asleep be asleep, and let those who are awake be awake.”

    The source says this.

    Let those who are asleep be asleep, and let those who are awake be awake

    William Henderson, Notes on the Folk-Lore of the Northern Counties of England and the Borders, 1879, Internet Archive

  7. “The girl jumps up, pushes him down the steps, and locks the door.”

    The source says this.

    pushed him down the steps. She then shut the door, locked it

    William Henderson, Notes on the Folk-Lore of the Northern Counties of England and the Borders, 1879, Internet Archive

  8. “She shouts, and shakes the family, but nobody wakes.”

    The source says this.

    calling, shouting, and shaking were alike in vain

    William Henderson, Notes on the Folk-Lore of the Northern Counties of England and the Borders, 1879, Internet Archive

  9. “So she runs down, takes a bowl of skimmed milk, and throws it over the hand and the candle.”

    The source says this.

    skimmed milk), and threw it over the hand and candle

    William Henderson, Notes on the Folk-Lore of the Northern Counties of England and the Borders, 1879, Internet Archive

  10. “She goes back up, and they wake at once.”

    The source says this.

    awoke the sleepers without any difficulty

    William Henderson, Notes on the Folk-Lore of the Northern Counties of England and the Borders, 1879, Internet Archive

Facts 31 to 40

  1. “The landlord’s son fires at them instead.”

    The source says this.

    This he refused, and fired among them

    William Henderson, Notes on the Folk-Lore of the Northern Counties of England and the Borders, 1879, Internet Archive

  2. “In the morning, a trail of blood leads away from the inn.”

    The source says this.

    stains of blood were traced to a considerable distance

    William Henderson, Notes on the Folk-Lore of the Northern Counties of England and the Borders, 1879, Internet Archive

  3. “In 1861 an old woman called Bella Parkin tells this story. She lives close to the inn. The servant girl was her mother.”

    The source says this.

    named Bella Parkin, who resided close to High Spital, and was actually the daughter of the courageous servant-girl

    William Henderson, Notes on the Folk-Lore of the Northern Counties of England and the Borders, 1879, Internet Archive

  4. “In January 1831, in County Meath in Ireland, robbers break into a house carrying a dead man’s hand with a lighted candle in it.”

    The source says this.

    night of the 3rd instant (January 1831), some Irish thieves

    William Henderson, Notes on the Folk-Lore of the Northern Counties of England and the Borders, 1879, Internet Archive, a document of the time

  5. “The people inside wake up. The robbers run, and leave the hand behind.”

    The source says this.

    the robbers fled, leaving the hand behind them

    William Henderson, Notes on the Folk-Lore of the Northern Counties of England and the Borders, 1879, Internet Archive, a document of the time

  6. “By 1840 the Hand of Glory is a story for the fireside. Richard Barham puts it in a comic poem, and gives his witch a charm.”

    The source says this.

    Matthew Hopkins himself has assured us that when

    Thomas Ingoldsby (Richard Harris Barham), The Ingoldsby Legends, 1843 edition, Internet Archive, a document of the time

  7. “Now open lock To the Dead Man’s knock! Fly bolt, and bar, and band! … Sleep all who sleep!—Wake all who wake!— And be as the Dead for the Dead Man’s sake!”

    The source says this.

    To the Dead Man’s knock

    Thomas Ingoldsby (Richard Harris Barham), The Ingoldsby Legends, 1843 edition, Internet Archive, a document of the time

  8. “In 1891 the vicar of Danby, the parish Castleton is in, writes about a woman called Hannah.”

    The source says this.

    Hannah

    J. C. Atkinson, Forty Years in a Moorland Parish: Reminiscences and Researches in Danby in Cleveland, 1891, Internet Archive, a document of the time

  9. “the parish Castleton is in”

    The source says this.

    This parish is composed of the township of Danby, which contains the market town of Castleton

    'Parishes: Danby', A History of the County of York North Riding: Volume 2, ed. William Page, 1923, British History Online

  10. “She is looking for her witch-wood: rowan, cut in the right season and the right place, to keep witches away.”

    The source says this.

    It must be cut in due season, and in due season only

    J. C. Atkinson, Forty Years in a Moorland Parish: Reminiscences and Researches in Danby in Cleveland, 1891, Internet Archive, a document of the time

Facts 41 to 44

  1. “He admitted he had no proof.”

    The source says this.

    Ford himself admits there’s no proof of any hangings at that spot

    Gallow Howe, fhithich.uk, 18 October 2023, quoting Joseph Ford, Some Reminiscences and Folk Lore of Danby Parish and District, 1953

    The sources disagree: The source is a blog’s summary of Ford’s book, not the book.

  2. “No other Hand of Glory is known to survive.”

    The source says this.

    the only alleged Hand known to survive

    The Hand of Glory, Whitby Museum

  3. “In 1935 it went to a museum on the Yorkshire coast”

    The source says this.

    given to Whitby Museum in 1935

    The Hand of Glory, Whitby Museum

  4. “and it is still there.”

    The source says this.

    13 February to 3 July

    Chronicle of Curiosities, Whitby Museum, February 2020

    The sources disagree: The museum’s page says it is on show; the exhibition it names closed in 2020.